Q1: What is the difference between a will and an estate plan?
A will is a single document that outlines who gets your assets and who will administer your estate after you die. An estate plan is more comprehensive – it may include a will plus other documents like powers of attorney, representation agreements, trusts, and strategies to handle taxes or probate. In short, your will is one important piece of the estate plan. The estate plan covers everything that happens to you and your property both in life (if you’re incapacitated) and at death. For example, an estate plan will address who makes medical decisions for you if you cannot, who gets your life insurance proceeds, and how to minimize probate fees, which a will alone may not cover. It’s best to have a holistic estate plan, and a wills & estates lawyer in BC can help craft one that fits your needs.
Q2: Why is having a will important?
Having a will is essential because it gives you control over what happens to your estate when you pass away. With a will, you decide who inherits each of your assets (rather than the default law deciding) and you can name an executor you trust to carry out your instructions. You can also include wishes for funeral arrangements and appoint a guardian for minor children, which is very important for parents. A will greatly simplifies things for your family – assets can be distributed more quickly and smoothly, and there’s less room for confusion or conflict. Without a will, as we covered, the law in BC will distribute your estate in a set way that might not reflect your wishes, and it could cause delays or extra costs. In short, a will ensures your voice is heard after you’re gone, sparing your loved ones unnecessary stress and uncertainty.
Q3: What happens if I die without a will in British Columbia?
If you die without a will in BC, you are “intestate”, and the Wills, Estates and Succession Act will determine how your estate is divided. Generally, your nearest family members inherit: for example, a spouse and children will get priority shares (spouse gets the first $300,000 or $150,000, depending on if the children are from that relationship, then the remainder is split). If you have no spouse or children, then it goes to parents, then siblings, etc., down the family line. Close friends, unmarried partners (under 2 years of cohabitation), stepchildren, or charities would not receive anything under intestacy. Also, someone (usually a family member) must apply to the court to be the administrator of your estate, which takes time. Minors’ inheritances are held in trust until they turn 19. Intestacy can lead to delays, and your assets might be tied up while the court process unfolds. Ultimately, not having a will means you have no say in who manages or benefits from your estate, so it’s highly recommended to make a will to avoid this situation.
Q4: Who can make a will in BC, and what are the legal requirements?
In BC, anyone 16 or older who is mentally capable can make a will. The will must be in writing and must be signed by the will-maker in the presence of two witnesses at the same time, and then signed by those two witnesses. The witnesses should be 19 or older, and should not be people who are receiving anything under the will (beneficiaries) or the spouse of a beneficiary. These formal requirements are critical – if they aren’t met, the will could be declared invalid. You also need to have the mental capacity to understand what a will is and the effects of your decisions (this is usually only an issue if someone has cognitive impairment or is under undue influence). As of 2021, BC also recognizes electronic wills (wills signed electronically and stored as electronic records) and even wills signed remotely via video in certain cases, but specific rules apply. For most people, a traditional paper will, properly signed and witnessed, is the surest way. It’s best to have a lawyer prepare the will or at least get legal advice to ensure it’s done right. Remember, handwritten unwitnessed wills (holographic wills) are generally not valid in BC, unlike in some other provinces.
Q5: Do I need a lawyer to write my will, or can I do it myself?
Legally in BC, you do not require a lawyer to draft a will – you can write your own will. However, while DIY will kits or online forms exist, it’s highly advisable to use a lawyer for most situations. A lawyer will ensure the will is properly executed and tailored to your circumstances. They can provide guidance on things you might not think of, like what happens if a beneficiary predeceases you, or how to structure a trust for a minor. Mistakes in wording or execution can render a will ineffective or lead to unintended outcomes. For example, if a layperson writes their own will, they might accidentally fail to dispose of all assets (resulting in a partial intestacy) or use unclear language that causes confusion or litigation. Given that a will only takes effect when you’re no longer around to clarify, it needs to be crystal clear and legally sound. Hiring a wills & estates lawyer (such as Merchant Law Group in Surrey) is worth the relatively modest cost for the peace of mind it provides. That said, if you have a very simple situation (e.g., a single beneficiary and few assets) and choose to do it yourself, be sure to follow BC’s signing requirements strictly and consider having a notary or lawyer review it.
Q6: How much does it cost to have a will made in BC?
The cost of making a will in British Columbia can vary widely depending on the complexity of your estate and the fee structure of the professional helping you. If you go to a lawyer, many offer will-drafting services either for a flat fee or at their hourly rate. Simple wills (for a person with a straightforward situation) might range on the lower end (e.g., a few hundred dollars). More complex estate plans (involving multiple documents like trusts, multiple wills, etc.) could be more, perhaps upwards of a thousand dollars or more. According to some averages, a basic will drafted by a lawyer might cost around $400-$600, while comprehensive estate planning packages (will, power of attorney, representation agreement) might be $1,000 to $2,500 or more. The Merchant Law Group notes that the average cost of a will and estate plan in BC ranges from $400 up to $3,000, depending on complexity. If you use a notary public for a simple will, their fees may be comparable. Using an online will service can be cheaper (often under $200), but those are generally DIY and you’re paying for a template and maybe a guided questionnaire, not personalized legal advice. Keep in mind that spending a bit on a well-drafted will now can save much more money (and stress) down the line by preventing mistakes or disputes. Always inquire about fees upfront – any reputable lawyer will be happy to provide an estimate based on your needs.
Q7: What is probate and why is it needed?
Probate is the court process of officially recognizing a will and authorizing an executor to act. When someone dies and leaves a will, the executor usually applies for Probate in the BC Supreme Court. The result is a Grant of Probate, a legal document confirming the will is valid and the executor has the right to deal with the estate. Probate is often needed because banks, Land Title Office, investment companies, and others will want proof that the person asking to access or transfer assets has proper authority. Without probate, for example, a bank won’t release a large bank account to the executor for distribution, because the bank could be liable if the will later turns out to be invalid or if a different executor was appointed. Probate effectively “unlocks” the estate assets for the executor to manage and eventually distribute. It also cuts off claims from those who might come forward with another will – once a will is probated, it’s considered the last valid will unless successfully challenged. In summary, probate provides legal certainty to the process of settling an estate. That said, if an estate is very small or everything was jointly owned or had named beneficiaries, probate might not be required. But in most cases where there’s real estate in the deceased’s name, significant investments, or multiple beneficiaries, probate is necessary to lawfully pass those assets on.
Q8: How long does probate take in BC?
The timeline for probate in BC can vary, but generally, once the application is submitted, it often takes about 6 to 12 weeks (1.5 to 3 months) to obtain the Grant of Probate for a straightforward estate. This assumes all the paperwork is in order and there are no challenges or questions from the court. However, getting to the point of submitting the probate application can itself take some weeks, as the executor must gather information, value assets, and prepare court forms. If the court registry is busy or if the application has issues (like a missing document), it could take longer. In more complex estates – for example, if there are overseas assets, or if someone files a notice of dispute to contest the will – probate can take significantly longer, even a year or more to resolve. It’s also worth noting that beneficiaries typically don’t receive their inheritances immediately after probate is granted. The executor still needs time to collect assets, pay debts and taxes, etc., before final distribution. In BC, beneficiaries often see distributions anywhere from a few months to a year after death, depending on complexity. The entire estate administration process (including probate and winding up the estate) frequently takes a year or two for completion. Patience is important, but if you’re an executor, keeping beneficiaries informed can help manage expectations.
Q9: How much are probate fees in British Columbia?
Probate fees in BC are set by the provincial government and are based on the value of the estate. The formula is straightforward: $0 on the first $25,000, $6 per $1,000 for the next $25,000 (i.e., $25k to $50k), and $14 per $1,000 for everything over $50,000. In percentage terms, that works out to about 1.4% of the estate’s gross value above $50,000. For example, if an estate is worth $100,000, the probate fee would be $0 for the first $25k, $150 for the next $25k (which is $6 * 25), and $14 * 50 for the amount above $50k (that’s $700). Total = $850. On a $1,000,000 estate, the fee would be roughly $13,450. These fees are paid out of the estate to the BC government when the probate application is filed. In addition, there’s a filing fee (around $200) for the application itself. Keep in mind, these are not income taxes or inheritance taxes (BC has none of those) – they are more like administrative taxes for using the courts to probate. Also, if an estate includes assets that are outside BC, those might not count towards BC’s probate fees if they require separate probate elsewhere. Note that hiring a lawyer to handle probate will incur legal fees as well, which are separate from the government probate fees.
Q10: What does an executor do?
An executor is the person named in a will who is responsible for administering the estate of the deceased. In other words, the executor carries out the instructions in the will and handles all the practical steps to settle the estate. Key duties of an executor include: locating the will, making funeral arrangements (often in consultation with family, and paying funeral expenses from the estate), applying for probate if needed, notifying beneficiaries and relevant institutions of the death, inventorying all assets and debts, safeguarding the assets (for example, making sure insurance continues on the house, maintaining property), paying off any debts and bills, filing tax returns for the deceased and the estate, and eventually distributing the remaining assets to the beneficiaries according to the will. The executor also has to keep records and might need to provide an accounting to the beneficiaries. Essentially, the executor “steps into the shoes” of the deceased in a legal sense to wind up the person’s affairs. It’s an important role that carries fiduciary responsibility – meaning the executor must act in the best interests of the estate and the beneficiaries, not themselves. Executors can hire professionals (lawyers, accountants) and pay them from the estate to help with tasks they’re not comfortable with. If you’re named as an executor and you feel you cannot do it, you can renounce (decline) as long as you haven’t already started acting in the role. Being an executor can be time-consuming, so it’s considered an honour but also a burden – that’s why people often choose a close family member or friend whom they trust, or even a professional executor or trust company for complicated estates.
Q11: Can an executor be paid for their work?
Yes, an executor in BC is generally entitled to compensation for the work they do, up to a certain limit. If the will specifies a fee or gift for the executor, that will apply. If the will is silent, BC’s law (Trustee Act) allows a “fair and reasonable” fee of up to 5% of the gross value of the estate (including capital and income receipts). In addition, if managing the estate takes a long time, the executor can also charge up to about 0.4% per year of the average value of the estate as a “care and management” fee. In practice, many executors (especially if they are family members) either waive the fee or take something more in the range of 1-5% depending on the complexity of the estate. For example, if you handle an estate worth $500,000 and it’s moderately complex, a 3% fee would be $15,000 for the executor. Executor fees are subject to approval – the beneficiaries can agree on the fee, or if they don’t agree, the executor might have to have the accounts reviewed and approved by the court (a process called passing of accounts). It’s important to note that executor fees are taxable income for the executor, whereas an inheritance as a beneficiary is not taxed. Because of this, sometimes will-makers leave an executor an extra gift in the will (which isn’t taxed) instead of labelling it as a fee. But that has its own risks and should be structured carefully. In any case, yes, an executor can be compensated for their time and effort. If you’re writing a will, discuss with your lawyer what an appropriate executor fee or gift might be, and if you’re acting as an executor, keep track of your time and tasks if you intend to claim a fee.
Q12: What is the difference between an executor and an administrator of an estate?
An executor and an administrator fulfill similar roles – both are in charge of settling an estate – but the difference lies in how they are appointed. An executor is named in the deceased’s will. When that person dies, the executor will seek probate and then carry out the will’s instructions. An administrator, on the other hand, is appointed by the court when someone dies without a will (intestate), or if the named executors in a will can’t or won’t act. Essentially, if there is no valid will or no available executor, someone (usually next of kin) applies to the court to be the estate’s administrator. The court then issues a Grant of Administration (instead of Probate). The administrator’s job is similar – gather assets, pay debts, and distribute the estate – but since there’s no will, distribution is according to intestacy law. Also, an administrator may need to post a security bond (especially if they are out-of-province or if there are minors involved), which executors under a will typically don’t have to do because the will often waives that requirement. In summary, executor = named in a will by the deceased, administrator = appointed by the court when no executor is available. Both are legally known as a “personal representative” of the estate. One extra note: if there is a will but it doesn’t name an executor, or the named executor has died and there’s no alternate, then someone (usually a beneficiary) can apply to be administrator with will annexed (meaning they’ll administer according to the will). The roles are akin – the key difference is in how they got the authority to act.
Q13: What is a “Grant of Probate” or “Grant of Administration”?
A Grant of Probate (often just called “probate”) is the court’s official approval of a will and the authorization of the executor to proceed with estate administration. It’s essentially an order from the BC Supreme Court, issued under the court seal, that says “this is the deceased’s last valid will and [Name] is confirmed as the lawful executor.” An executor shows this document to banks, the land titles office, etc., as proof of their authority. A Grant of Administration is similar but issued when there is no will (or no executor), appointing an administrator to manage the estate. In both cases, the document might also be called a Representation Grant or Estate Grant. These grants are necessary in most cases to deal with the estate assets. Without a grant, the estate is in a bit of a legal limbo – no one has clear authority to sign on behalf of the deceased. Once a Grant of Probate or Administration is obtained, the personal representative can collect assets, pay debts, and ultimately distribute the estate. The process to get the grant involves submitting the will (if there is one), a detailed application, and sometimes supporting affidavits to the court. Think of the grant as the green light to move forward with settling the estate. In everyday terms, people often say, “We need to get probate,” which means to obtain the Grant of Probate.
Q14: Does British Columbia have an inheritance tax or estate tax?
No, British Columbia (and indeed all of Canada) does not have an inheritance tax or estate tax like some other countries do. In other words, when you die, your estate or your beneficiaries generally do not pay a special tax just for inheriting money or property. BC used to have an inheritance tax decades ago, but it was abolished in the 1980s. However, this doesn’t mean there are no tax consequences at all. When someone dies, there is usually a deemed disposition of their assets for income tax purposes. For example, if you have investments or a cottage that has gone up in value, it’s as if you sold it at death, and your estate might have to pay capital gains tax on the increase in value. Also, if you have RRSPs or RRIFs, those are often fully taxable as income in the year of death (unless rolling over to a spouse). The executor files a final income tax return and the estate pays any income taxes due out of estate funds. But these are just normal income taxes, not a tax on the inheritance itself. Once those taxes (and any probate fees) are paid, the beneficiaries receive their inheritance without any tax. They don’t count it as income, and Canada doesn’t impose any percentage cut. So if you inherit $50,000 from an estate, that’s yours with no tax payable on it (aside from any taxes the estate already settled before giving it to you). Always consider consulting a tax advisor as part of estate planning or administration, because while there’s no estate tax, careful planning can reduce the income taxes triggered at death (for example, by naming a spouse as beneficiary on registered accounts, or using the principal residence exemption, etc.).
Q15: What is a Power of Attorney and why might I need one?
A Power of Attorney (PoA) is a legal document in which you appoint someone to act on your behalf for financial and legal matters. You might need one to ensure that if you’re ever unable to manage your own affairs – say you’re travelling, ill, or incapacitated – someone you trust can step in and handle things for you. There are different types of PoA: a general Power of Attorney gives broad powers but ends if you become mentally incapable, whereas an Enduring Power of Attorney continues to be valid even if you can’t make decisions (this is the type most people want for incapacity planning). With an enduring PoA, your attorney (often a spouse, adult child, or close friend) could pay your bills, manage your bank accounts, renew your mortgage, or even sell your house if needed. Without a PoA, if you lose capacity, your family would have to apply to court for committeeship to get those powers, which is expensive and slow. Think of a PoA as insurance for your financial well-being during your lifetime. It only applies while you’re alive – the moment you die, the PoA is no longer effective (and your will and executor take over from there). Most seniors and indeed any adult who wants to be prepared should have a Power of Attorney in place, especially an enduring one, as part of their estate planning. It provides peace of mind that your bills will be paid and finances managed if you can’t do it yourself. It’s important to pick someone very trustworthy, because a PoA can be misused. In BC, you can also set conditions or restrictions in the PoA if you want to limit what your attorney can do or when the power kicks in.
Q16: Does a Power of Attorney allow someone to make health care decisions for me?
No, a standard Power of Attorney in BC does not cover health care or personal decisions – it is only for financial and legal matters. To authorize someone to make health or personal care decisions on your behalf, you need a Representation Agreement (for personal/health matters) or an Advance Directive (for specific health instructions). There is often confusion about this: people might think their “power of attorney” can tell doctors what to do if they’re in a coma, but that’s not the case under BC law. The person you name in a Power of Attorney (your attorney) can, for example, pay your care facility fees and manage your property, but cannot consent to surgery or decide on medical treatment for you. For health decisions, you would name a representative in a Representation Agreement. Some other provinces use terminology like “Personal Directive” or “Medical Power of Attorney,” but in BC, the documents are separate. It’s wise to have both an Enduring Power of Attorney and a Representation Agreement so that all aspects of your life are covered. One handles the money, the other handles health and personal care. You can choose the same person for both roles or different people, as you prefer. Just remember to discuss your wishes with them so they know how to act if the time comes.
Q17: What is a Representation Agreement in BC?
A Representation Agreement is a legal document unique to BC (other provinces have equivalents by different names) that allows you to appoint someone as your representative for health care and personal care decisions if you become unable to make those decisions yourself. In a representation agreement, you can give your representative authority to make a broad range of decisions, from where you live (e.g., moving you to a care home) to what medical treatments you receive or don’t receive. There are two levels: a standard Representation Agreement (Section 7) which can cover minor and major health care and personal care, and routine financial affairs, and an enhanced Representation Agreement (Section 9) which can cover refusing life-support and other significant health care decisions . The enhanced one requires you to fully understand what you’re doing when you sign it (basically, be mentally capable), whereas a standard one can be made even if someone has diminished capacity, to allow some support in decision-making. Most capable adults will do the enhanced version to cover all bases. In your RA, you can also include instructions or guidance for your representative, similar to an advance directive or living will, expressing your values or wishes (for example, some people state they don’t want heroic measures to prolong life in certain conditions). Representation agreements are important because, without one (or an advance directive), health care providers will defer to a default list of decision-makers (your spouse, then child, etc.), and that person might not know your wishes or there might be disagreement among family. Also, certain decisions like discontinuing life support or intrusive treatments can be easier if a trusted representative is clearly authorized to act. To make an RA, you must be 19 or older and sign the document in front of witnesses (or a notary/lawyer) with your representative also signing acceptance. It’s recommended to get legal advice when making one, to ensure it’s properly drafted and executed.
Q18: What is the difference between a Representation Agreement and an Advance Directive?
A Representation Agreement (RA) appoints a person (your representative) to make health and personal care decisions for you if you cannot, whereas an Advance Directive (AD) is a written document where you record specific health care instructions directly. Think of an advance directive as like a letter to doctors saying, “If I am ever in situation X, I do want treatment Y or I refuse treatment Z.” Commonly, people use ADs to refuse certain interventions (e.g., no CPR, no feeding tube if in permanent vegetative state, etc.). If you have a valid advance directive that clearly applies to your medical situation, health care providers are obligated to follow it as if you had given the instruction at the time. A representation agreement, on the other hand, doesn’t list all decisions, but empowers someone to decide things in real time on your behalf. You can have both: many people do an RA and also an AD to give their representative and doctors clear guidance. In BC, if you have both and they conflict, generally your own advance directive would take priority for the instructions it covers, and your representative would only decide on things not addressed in the AD. If you have strong wishes about end-of-life care, you might do an AD to state those, and still have an RA for flexibility in unforeseen situations.
If you do only one of the two: an AD alone means you’ve given specific instructions, but you haven’t appointed a decision-maker for anything you didn’t cover, then the health system falls back to a temporary substitute decision-maker list for other decisions. An RA alone means you’ve appointed someone but haven’t given written instructions – you trust them to make the call. Many lawyers include a basic advance directive (sometimes called a living will statement) within the representation agreement or as a supporting document. It’s all part of personal planning.
Q19: Can I name the same person to be my executor, power of attorney, and representative?
Absolutely, yes. You can name the same individual (or more than one) to take on all these roles, or you can choose different people – it’s entirely up to you. There can be advantages to naming the same person because they’ll have continuity from handling your finances during your life (if you become incapacitated) to handling your estate after death. For example, your spouse or your adult child might already be your attorney under a Power of Attorney and your representative under a Representation Agreement; it’s very common to also name that person as the executor in your will since they’ll be familiar with your affairs. However, consider the person’s ability and willingness to handle the workload and responsibility. Some people divide duties: maybe one child is good with finances, so they’re the attorney/executor, while another is a nurse so they’re the health care representative. That’s fine too. Just ensure the people you pick can collaborate if they need to. Also, remember that Power of Attorney and Representation Agreement are only effective while you’re alive, and the executor only takes over when you’ve passed away, so there’s no overlapping authority to worry about (the roles don’t conflict because they’re in effect at different times). It’s wise to talk to the person(s) you plan to name to make sure they’re willing to serve. No one is forced to take on these roles – executors can renounce, and attorneys/representatives can resign, so getting agreement in advance is key. And always name alternates in case your first choice can’t act when the time comes.
Q20: When should I update my will or estate plan?
You should update your will and estate plan whenever there’s a significant change in your life or intentions, and also periodically, even if nothing major has changed, just to keep it current. Common triggers for an update include: marriage or divorce (though marriage doesn’t cancel a will in BC, your new spouse or the departure of a spouse could mean you want different provisions), start of a common-law relationship or end of one, birth of children or grandchildren whom you want to include, death of a beneficiary or executor named in your will, significant changes in your assets (e.g., you bought property or started a business, or conversely, you sold major assets), or if you move to a different province or country (different laws might apply). Also, if laws change (for instance, a tax law or estate law that could affect your plan), an update might be wise. A good rule of thumb is to review your will every 3-5 years anyway, even if just to read it and say, “Is everything still what I want?” Estate plans are not “set and forget” because your family, assets, and even relationships can evolve. Minor updates can sometimes be done with a codicil (an amendment), but major changes usually mean drafting a new will. Don’t write on your will or cross things out as a way to update – that can invalidate it. Similarly, keep beneficiary designations (on life insurance, RRSPs, etc.) updated; they are part of your estate plan too. For Powers of Attorney or Representation Agreements, update those if, for example, the person you named has moved away or your relationship changed, or if their health now makes them unable to act when needed. Keeping your documents up to date ensures that when they’re needed, they reflect your current wishes and are aligned with your situation. Many lawyers will notify clients about law changes or do periodic check-ins, but it’s ultimately up to you to reach out and update.
Q21: Can I change or cancel my will or Power of Attorney later?
Yes, you retain the power to change or revoke these documents as long as you are mentally capable. For your will: you can either make a new will (which typically includes a clause revoking all previous wills) or add a codicil (an amendment) to modify parts of it. Tearing up a will can also revoke it, but that’s not advisable unless you really intend to destroy it and have a new plan – and never write on your will, as notes or scratches can cause legal questions. It’s best to see a lawyer to properly change your will. Remember that big life changes (marriage, etc.) might affect your will, so sometimes changes are automatic (e.g., if you divorce, any gift to your former spouse is typically revoked by law in BC).
For a Power of Attorney: you can revoke it at any time with a written Notice of Revocation, which you should give to the attorney and any institutions that have the PoA on file. Make sure to collect and destroy the original PoA documents so they can’t be used.
For a Representation Agreement: similarly, you can sign a revocation document or make a new one that states the old one is revoked. All these documents (will, PoA, RA) are under your control while you’re alive and competent. Once you lose capacity, you can’t change them (which is why planning ahead is so important). And of course, once you die, the will becomes irrevocable (you can’t change your will after death, obviously, and the PoA/RA cease at death). One more thing: if you make a new will, ensure any copies of the old one are marked as revoked or destroyed, so there’s no confusion about which is the latest will. And if you revoke a PoA, definitely inform banks or others that might rely on it that it’s revoked. A lawyer can assist with all these steps to ensure the changes are legally effective.
Q22: Can my spouse and I have a joint will or mirror wills?
In BC (and generally in Canada), joint wills (one document for two people) are not common and not recommended. Each person should have their own will, because each person’s estate is separate. What couples often do is make mirror wills – meaning the wills are separate but almost identical in content (for example, each leaves everything to the other, and if the other is predeceased, then to the kids). That’s perfectly fine. You just need to be aware that mirror wills are not legally binding on the survivor – either spouse can change their will after the first one dies. Some couples want a binding arrangement (especially in second marriages with separate children, etc.) and might consider a contract or mutual will agreement that says neither will change their will after one dies. Those are called mutual wills, and they are a more complex area – they basically restrict the survivor from changing the plan. If that’s a concern (e.g., wanting to ensure assets ultimately go to certain children, not a new partner, after one’s death), you should talk to a lawyer about alternate approaches like trusts or agreements. But for the average couple, simple mirror wills are fine and common. For example: Husband’s will – “I leave everything to my wife, and if she’s gone, to our children equally”; Wife’s will – “I leave everything to my husband, and if he’s gone, to our children equally.” This covers most bases. Just remember to update if both of you pass your estate to the same beneficiaries, because if one spouse changes their will later, there’s no automatic notice to the other. Also, note that a will only controls assets in your name. Joint assets with right of survivorship go directly to the joint survivor, regardless of the will, and designated beneficiaries on accounts or life insurance go directly to those beneficiaries. So, joint or mirror wills should be part of an overall strategy, considering those non-estate assets as well.
Q23: What are the rights of a common-law spouse in estate matters in BC?
In BC, a common-law spouse (referred to as a spouse in BC law if you have lived together in a marriage-like relationship for at least 2 years, or are in a registered domestic partnership) generally has similar rights to a married spouse when it comes to estate matters. This is a bit different from some other places – BC recognizes common-law partners for intestacy and wills variation. So, if you die without a will, your common-law spouse of 2+ years is considered a spouse and will inherit under intestacy (just like a married spouse would). If you have a will and you leave them little or nothing, they have the same right to challenge the will for a better share as a married spouse would. However, note the 2+ years requirement – a partner of, say, 1 year is not a spouse under WESA. Also, if you were separated (intending to live apart permanently, even if not formally divorced) at the time of death, then that person may no longer be considered a spouse for estate purposes Separation can cut off spousal rights if clearly established. So it’s possible, for example, to be legally married but separated for a year – in that case, the surviving spouse might not be entitled under intestacy or allowed to vary the will, because WESA says a spouse does not include someone who was “separated” from the deceased at death (specific criteria apply). It can get complicated to determine spouse status if there’s an on-and-off relationship.
In summary: a common-law spouse in BC who meets the time threshold is treated essentially the same as a married spouse for estate inheritance and will-contest purposes. They do not, however, automatically have rights like dower or something – it’s through either the will, intestacy law, or wills variation. For that reason, it’s always best to make your wishes clear in a will. If you want to provide for your common-law partner, do so explicitly in a will (especially if under 2 years together, since intestacy wouldn’t recognize them). If you do not want to provide for a long-term common-law partner, be aware that they can make a claim, and you should seek legal advice on how to structure things or your reasons (but the court can still override a will to provide for them).
Q24: Can I disinherit my spouse or children in my will in BC?
You can attempt to disinherit anyone in your will since, as a will-maker, you have the freedom to distribute your estate, but in BC, disinheriting a spouse or child can be legally challenging. BC’s wills variation law allows a spouse or biological/adopted child to ask the court to vary (change) the will if it doesn’t make adequate provision for them. The court balances the will-maker’s wishes against what would be a “reasonable” legacy for the spouse/child. So, if you completely cut out a spouse or child without very good reason, there’s a high chance the court might award them a share if they contest it. The law in BC basically expects you to fulfill your moral and legal obligations to your spouse and children through your will. There are cases where disinheriting can hold – for example, if you have an adult child with whom you had no relationship for decades and you have a written statement explaining the estrangement, the court might accept that as a valid reason. Or if you provided significantly for a child during life and balanced things differently in the will. For spouses, it’s hard to completely disinherit a long-time spouse; even if separated but not legally ended the relationship, things can be messy. You cannot disinherit a minor child from necessary support because their guardian could claim support from the estate as well. So, while technically you can write a will leaving nothing to a certain child or spouse, expect a court challenge and likely a redistribution if that person pursues it. If you truly want to leave a spouse or child nothing (or a nominal amount), get detailed legal advice. You might consider life insurance or other outside-of-estate transfers to satisfy what might be their claim. Also, stepchildren (not adopted) you can disinherit with no WESA recourse (they can’t vary a will because they aren’t included in the definition of children for that), but if you’ve treated them as your own, you might feel a moral obligation anyway. In summary: Yes, you can legally state those terms in your will, but in BC the disinherited spouse/kids have the right to challenge and potentially override your wishes via the courts. Each case turns on its facts and the estate’s size, the claimant’s circumstances, and the reasons for disinheritance.
Q25: What can I do if I think a will is not valid or was made under undue influence?
If you believe a will is not valid – for instance, the person lacked capacity, or it wasn’t executed properly, or they were unduly influenced – you should seek legal advice promptly. You may have grounds to contest the will. In BC, the process would typically involve filing a Notice of Dispute at the Probate Registry (if probate hasn’t been granted yet) to put the brakes on the probate process. Then, you might need to bring a court application or action to challenge the will’s validity. Grounds to challenge include: the deceased didn’t have mental capacity to understand the will at the time (e.g., advanced dementia); the will was signed under undue influence (someone pressured or coerced them); fraud (maybe a page was swapped, or the signature was forged); or that the will doesn’t meet the formal execution requirements (though note: WESA gives the court power to cure some deficiencies, so even a technical flaw might be overcome unless it’s a holographic will, which BC doesn’t accept generally). If the court finds the will invalid, it might revive a previous will or, if none, the estate goes intestate. Undue influence can be hard to prove – often it’s suspected if an elderly person radically changed their will in favor of a caregiver or one child to the exclusion of others. Suspicious circumstances can shift burden of proof onto the will proponent to show it was voluntary. You typically need evidence (medical records, witnesses, patterns of isolation, etc.). Because time limits and legal intricacies exist, contacting an estate litigation lawyer quickly is key. If you’re a beneficiary or potential heir who was surprised by a will that seems fishy, you have standing to challenge it. If probate has already been granted and you discover issues, you still can challenge, but it’s better to intervene early. The process can be costly and is essentially a court case – sometimes it settles out of court. Keep in mind a different scenario: if the will is valid but just “unfair,” that’s where wills variation comes in (for spouse/child). But if it’s truly not the person’s will (due to incapacity or undue influence), that’s a validity challenge as described. In any case, acting promptly and gathering any supporting facts are important steps.
Q26: How can I minimize the chances of my will being challenged?
To minimize the chances of your will being challenged or a successful challenge, consider these steps while planning:
- Use a lawyer: A professionally drafted will with a lawyer’s oversight will reduce technical challenges (like allegations of improper execution or doubts about validity). The lawyer can also document your capacity and that you were not under undue influence.
- Capacity precautions: If there could be any question about your mental capacity (perhaps you’re older or have early cognitive issues), get a doctor’s assessment near the time of making the will. This medical evidence can later prove you knew what you were doing.
- Avoid undue influence appearances: Make sure the signing is done without any beneficiary present, and tell your lawyer in private what you want. If you’re leaving a disproportionate share to someone who is in a position of power over you (like a caregiver), be extra careful – the lawyer might want to ask more questions or even do multiple meetings to ensure it’s truly your wish.
- Communicate your reasoning: One common cause of challenges is shock or hurt feelings. If appropriate, consider explaining your decisions to family members in advance, especially if you are doing something unusual (e.g., leaving more to one child). While you don’t legally have to, sometimes a conversation or a letter (separate from the will) explaining your rationale can reduce resentment. On the other hand, if discussing it would cause strife now, you might leave a side letter for after your death to be read. (Be cautious: a letter could also become evidence in a wills variation case – consult your lawyer on this.)
- Include a memorandum of reasons for disinheritance (if applicable): If you intend to disinherit a spouse or child or leave an unequal share, your lawyer can include a statement of reasons in the will or as an affidavit. While not legally binding on a court, it provides evidence of your wishes and rationale, which a court may take into account. For example, you might note you provided significant support to one child during life, or that you have estranged relations with another. Ensure the reasons are fact-based and not vindictive or based on traits (like “I disinherit my son because of his lifestyle” could actually backfire as a bad reason).
- Consider strategic gifts or life insurance: Sometimes, even if you want to benefit one person more, it can help to leave something to others to dissuade them from contesting. A token amount might not be enough (and in wills variation, a small amount may be treated similar to nothing), but if feasible, leaving reasonably for each spouse/child can avoid court. Alternatively, using life insurance or joint ownership to pass assets outside the will can help – though be careful, those can also be attacked if done in a suspicious way.
- Keep your will up to date: Challenges sometimes arise when a will is outdated and doesn’t reflect current promises or expectations. If you’ve promised something to someone (like “I’ll leave you the house”), better to reflect it formally or explicitly not, to avoid surprise claims.
- Executor choice: Pick an executor who is likely to be neutral and competent. A trusted executor who treats everyone fairly can sometimes diffuse tensions and handle minor disputes without litigation.
In the end, you cannot make a will 100% challenge-proof in BC, because spouses and children will always have the option to claim for a better share. But by being fair (or having clear reasons if not) and using proper legal guidance, you can reduce the risk of a successful challenge. And remember, you won’t be around to explain, so whatever explanation or evidence you’d want a court to know, you have to put it on record beforehand.
Q27: What does probate or estate administration assistance from a lawyer include?
If you hire a lawyer in BC to assist with probate or administering an estate, they can handle as much or as little as you need. For probate, a lawyer will typically: gather necessary information about assets, draft and file all the court documents for the probate application (including the affidavit of assets/liabilities, notices to beneficiaries, etc.), deal with any issues the probate registry raises, and obtain the Grant of Probate. This service alone can be a relief to executors who are unfamiliar with the legal forms and requirements. Once probate is obtained, for estate administration, the lawyer can help the executor in various tasks: preparing advertisements for creditors, advising on selling or transferring assets (and preparing deeds or transmissions for land titles, for example), ensuring debts and taxes are properly handled (often coordinating with an accountant for tax returns), preparing releases for beneficiaries to sign upon distribution, and drafting a final accounting or receipts. If there are any legal disputes or claims (like a family member not happy with their share or a claim from a creditor), the lawyer will advise on how to handle those or represent the estate in legal proceedings if necessary. Essentially, the lawyer acts as a guide and problem-solver through the entire process. For instance, if a beneficiary can’t be located, the lawyer can assist with steps to find them or get court direction. If any assets are in other provinces, the lawyer can coordinate secondary probate there through affiliates. Also, if the will has ambiguous terms, the lawyer can help interpret them or seek a court interpretation. Using a lawyer can also shield the executor – by getting proper advice, the executor is less likely to make a mistake that could result in personal liability. Many firms, like Merchant Law Group in Surrey, have dedicated estate administration lawyers or paralegals who handle the procedural heavy-lifting, allowing the executor to focus on family matters and decision-making rather than paperwork. The cost for this is usually paid out of the estate, not by the executor personally, and fees may be hourly or sometimes a percentage. It’s usually money well spent if the executor is at all unsure about the process.
Q28: Do I need to register my will with the government in BC?
No, you are not required to register your will with the government for it to be valid. In BC, a will’s validity comes from meeting the legal signing and witnessing requirements, not from any registration. However, BC has an optional Wills Registry (run by the Vital Statistics Agency) where you can file a Wills Notice. This notice simply records the existence of your will and where it is located (for example, “Will dated Jan 1, 2025, stored at ABC Law Firm in Surrey”). The content of your will is not filed, just the information about its whereabouts. The Wills Registry can be searched after death by your executor to see if a notice was filed, which helps ensure they find the correct, latest will. The fee to file a wills notice is small (about $17). Many lawyers automatically file this notice when they draft a will for a client. If you update your will later, a new notice can be filed. The Wills Registry is a useful tool to prevent situations where a will is lost or unknown. But it’s not mandatory – plenty of wills are not registered. If you don’t register, just be sure your executor knows where the original will is kept (since an original is needed for probate). After a death, a search of the registry is commonly done by lawyers handling the estate to make sure there isn’t a more recent will notice on file.
In summary: not required, but consider registering the will’s location for safety. And regardless, keep your will in a secure place and inform your executor or family of how to access it when needed.
Q29: Where should I keep my will and other estate documents?
You should store your original will (and other important estate planning documents like power of attorney and representation agreement) in a safe, secure location where it can be found when needed. Common choices include: a fireproof home safe or lockbox, a safety deposit box at a bank, or your lawyer’s vault (many law firms will hold clients’ original wills for safekeeping at no or little charge). If you keep it in a safety deposit box, ensure your executor either has access or can gain access; in BC, banks will allow a safety deposit box to be opened to search for a will and life insurance after death, but there are formalities. Wherever you keep it, it’s crucial that your executor and perhaps one other trusted person know the location (and any access details like a key or combination). Do not hide it so well that no one can find it. Also, do not remove staples or attachments from your will – if the will was stapled and staples are removed (for photocopying, etc.), it can raise questions at probate about whether pages were altered. Keep it intact. It’s wise to keep other documents together with the will, such as a list of your assets/accounts (to help your executor), funeral wishes, or insurance policies. Some people give a copy of the will to their executor or discuss the contents in advance, which can be helpful. Just remember the original signed will is what the court needs. For Powers of Attorney and Representation Agreements (which are used during your life if needed), you should keep the originals handy (not locked away in a bank where nobody can get them when needed). Often, people keep those at home or give the original PoA to the named attorney for use.
Another tip: tell your family if you have made a will. If they believe you didn’t and you actually did, they might distribute assets or make court applications, not knowing a will exists. A will’s notice registry filing can prevent that scenario as well. In summary, choose a secure but accessible spot for your estate documents and ensure your key people are aware.
Q30: Are there any estate planning steps particularly important for residents of Surrey or BC specifically?
Most estate planning principles are similar across provinces, but for BC (and thus Surrey residents), here are a few BC-specific points to note:
- Wills Variation (Family Maintenance) claims: As discussed, BC is one of the few provinces that allow adult children to challenge a will for fairness. This means BC will-makers should be mindful of making adequate provision for spouses and kids, or explicitly acknowledge and justify if they don’t. People relocating from other provinces or countries to BC might not realize this difference.
- No probate tax but significant probate fees: BC doesn’t have an estate tax, but the probate fee of ~1.4% is on the higher side compared to some provinces. So, probate avoidance strategies (like naming beneficiaries, joint ownership, trusts) are sometimes more utilized in BC.
Be cautious though: don’t add joint owners or designate beneficiaries without advice, as it can have other consequences. But it’s a consideration for BC residents, perhaps more than in provinces with flat, low probate costs.
- Property transfer considerations: BC has a property transfer tax (PTT) that can sometimes be triggered if you transfer real estate to joint ownership as a planning tool (except between spouses). Also, if you will property to a foreign beneficiary, the BC government now has a “speculation and vacancy tax” and other things that might be triggered – minor points, but worth getting local advice if that applies.
- Representation Agreements: Only BC (and the Yukon) use the term representation agreements for health care. If you moved here from elsewhere, the equivalent of your “health care directive” or “power of personal care” needs to be conformed to BC law. BC’s system is unique with two types of RA and an advance directive option. Surrey has a large, diverse population, and making sure your family understands your chosen decision-makers (especially in cultures where family might expect decisions to be collective) is important.
- First Nations lands: If you hold property on First Nations land or are a First Nations individual, there might be unique rules under federal jurisdiction for estate matters (the Indian Act has provisions for estates of status Indians on reserve, etc.). This is specific but worth noting if applicable.
- Multiple wills for business assets: This is a more advanced strategy – some provinces allow multiple wills (one for assets that don’t require probate and one for those that do) to save probate fees. Ontario uses that commonly for shares in private corporations. BC’s law doesn’t clearly disallow multiple wills, and some lawyers do utilize them here too. If you have significant business assets, ask a BC lawyer about this strategy.
- Digital assets and crypto: This is not BC-specific, but ensure to include plans for digital assets (social media, online accounts) and any cryptocurrency you might own. Provide access info to your executor in a secure way, because these can be easily lost.
- Funeral arrangements: In BC, you can leave funeral and burial/cremation wishes in your will or other document, but they are not legally binding (they serve as guidance). The executor or next of kin has the legal right to control the disposal of the body. If you have strong wishes (especially if they might conflict with your family’s wishes), talk to your family or leave very clear instructions and maybe appoint someone you trust as executor who will honour those wishes.
- “Make a Will Week”: BC has an annual Make-a-Will Week (often in April) to encourage will planning – perhaps use that as a reminder to review your plans.
In summary, the core steps (will, PoA, RA, etc.) are crucial for anyone in Surrey/BC. The nuances above are things a local BC wills & estates lawyer would know to discuss based on your circumstances. Surrey being in BC means you benefit from BC’s modern legislation (WESA) but also must plan within its framework.
To The Top